Futures-Based ETFs





Kerry Back

  • Futures-based ETFs hold futures contracts
  • Value of fund = cash used for margin
  • Example: USO holds crude futures
  • Return on futures-based ETF \(\neq\) % change in commodity price

Futures vs spot returns

Futures returns

  • Typical strategy: buy contracts 2 or 3 months out
  • When the contract becomes the front month contract, sell it and buy new contracts 2 or 3 months out.
  • Return = % change in futures price 2 or 3 months \(\rightarrow\) 1 month
  • \(\neq\) % change in front month price

Futures roll

  • Consider a forward curve with months to maturity on the x axis.
  • Consider a contract with expiration at a certain date.
  • As time passes, the location of this contract on the curve moves to the left (months to maturity become less).
  • If the forward curve doesn’t move, then
    • The futures price of the contract falls if the market is in contango
    • And rises if the market is in backwardation

  • Consider buying a contract 2 months out at date \(t\) and hold it for 2 months (date \(t+2\)). At \(t+2\), its price is the spot price.
  • Gain is \(\text{spot}_{t+2} - \text{futures}_t\).
  • This equals

\[\text{spot}_{t+2} - \text{spot}_t\] \[+ \text{spot}_{t} - \text{futures}_t\]

  • 2nd row is \(<0\) in contango and \(>0\) in backwardation.

Gold example

History of USO

History of spot crude prices

Normalized histories

Forward Curves

Levered Index ETFs

  • Examples: SPXL, SPXS (L=Long, S=Short) are 3x levered
  • Each day hold futures contracts (long or short) with

\[\text{# contracts}\times \text{contract size} \times \text{futures price}\] \[= 3 \times \text{fund equity}\]

Daily SPXL returns versus daily SPY returns

Daily SPXS returns versus daily SPY returns

SPY, SPXL, and SPXS returns

Principles about levered etfs

  • In an up-and-down market, both levered long and levered short ETFs lose money.
  • In trending markets, levered ETFs do better than leverage ratios indicate.
  • In an upward (downward) trending market, a levered long ETF outperforms by more (underperforms by less) than the leverage ratio.
  • Due to daily rebalancing. For a levered long ETF, $ at risk rise on positive returns and fall on down returns.